magura mt trail sport vs shimano xt

Considering upgrading the XTs to magura mt7 or is there a way to get the XTs to feel a little more like maguras? After 4 rides in horrible conditions in Tasmania the brakes never lost bite or became contaminated, however they were noisy but as the weather dried up the noise subsided immediately. Installing new pads is a breeze due to the magnetic design that snap the pads into place. I run 203mm front and 180mm rear. The good news is that Magura's two-piston systems all use the same pad shape. What are you guys impression of the difference between these brakes? Min-Max, The 203mm front and 180mm rear provide plenty of stopping power. Tags: I will keep my Trail Sport review brief as it was a short affair, but I did learn a lot (I will go into detail in the MT5 review). The air was filled with the smell of hot metal as every parameter was measured, recorded and logged with unflinching accuracy. On paper, the Magura MT Trail Sports make sense: a powerful MT5 4-piston caliper on the front, and a smaller, MT4 2-piston caliper on the back, where the power requirements are less. Loose surfaces, weather conditions and endless lines make direct comparison impossible. It fucking rules. Parts for Shimano brakes are pretty common. So you assembled your own MT Trail Sport system? Shimano MT501 + MT520 . I bleed my own brakes and recently didn't do the best job. Longer pad and rotor life. Really cant go wrong with either. I'm interested in peoples experience and opinions in which brakes to upgrade to. XT vs. Magura Trail Sport vs. Formula Cura - Mountain Bike Reviews Forum Your email address will not be published. Besides being accustomed to bad weather he's a specialist when it comes to steep and demanding trails. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, Sunshine Coast - Canada 2021 Forbidden Druid, Brakes are for people who lack commitment, Trek Session / YT Capra / Orbea Rise / PBJ. Shimano has an inconsistent bite point on a lot of their brakes. The I-Spec EV, Shimano's latest . I have both and both are great. **front + rear, w/o rotors. Braking, like most aspects of life, is a personal thing: some like their brakes to initially engage with the smoothness of two greased feathers pressing against the disc, while others like to feel deceleration as violent as a chain strung between the trees. I fine tuned the Caliper using 5he hols to reseat-it in alignment with the disk. Blue highlights signify Magura's MT Trail Brake four pistons up front, with two pistons in the rear caliper, paired with 180mm rotors (Pictured: Storm SL front and a Storm HC rear). With the 203mm Magura Storm HC rotors up front and 180mm at the back, coupled with the mix of 4 and 2 pistons, we had a consistent braking performance over the rowdiest of terrain. I've had the shop bleed them twice in 200kms since new. Shimano Altus BR-MT200 Organische Achterrem (zonder schijf) 170cm Zwart I can make a strong argument for Performance with the four-pistons. With the DUSTY, the Spanish brand are taking a new direction in 2023, launching their first e-gravel bike. This makes the tolerances quite tight. Once correctly bedded in and with no increases in braking torque observed, the testing could begin. Do you get a wandering bite point with this setup? Changing front fork travel from 170 to 180. Shimano SLX BR-M7120 Disc Brake $186.99 (18) Award Winner. Magura has packed a ton of value into the MT Trail Sport brakes, without sacrificing performance. No matter how good the levers, or how large the pistons, all the braking forces are transferred by the brake pads onto the discs. Currently running Shiguras, but have done Saint, XT and MT5 in the past. Are you with us? Get the latest industry news direct to your inbox. Quick-Fit Adapters are designed to work with Jagwire Pro Hydraulic Hose 20 powerful decelerations from 35-15 km/h, 20 cycles from 35-0 km/h and finally the toughest test of all, 10 repeated hard cycles pulling down from 45-0 km/h. Both stop in their own way and both have excellent stopping power. The XTR brakes feel like pretty much every other Shimano brake. . Up front was another matter. Shimano XT M8120 Trail Magura MT Trail Sport Shimano MT501 + MT520 3 reviews 5 reviews 17 reviews 0 reviews Composition: Set / Front brake / Rear brake: Set / Front brake / Rear brake: Set: Set / Front brake / Rear brake . Discos de freno Magura MT eStop Flotantes para ebike (180, 203 y 200mm) For those who love smooth modulation, then the TRP Quadiem, Hope and SRAM Guide offer the most linear deceleration. Is it the modulation you think better of? $96.99. Every category should benefit from powerful, reliable braking! I have the MT trail sports, they are a mix of a 4pot mt5 at the front and a 2 pot mt4 at the back. On the dyno the brakes were bedded in with 20 cycles of 1 second pulls from 15 km/h, then 20 cycles of 2 second pulls from 15 km/h, repeated twice. My 2020 Levo Level T brakes are also a big letdown. JavaScript is disabled. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. The Trail Sports have a four piston up front. Magura's MT Trail brake system is not going to impress ham-fisted riders who use the rear wheel like a rudder to mash down steeps. The MT Trail Sport set utilizes the same 42 piston setup at a sliver of the price. Trevor loves adventure. Instead, I use 2.3mm ebike rotors and the power is nutty. Magur MT trail sport vs Shimano Trail sport : r/mountainbiking German brand Magura has been in the brake business for quite some time - over a hundred years on the motorsports side - and while they may not hold the same chunk of OEM sales that the red and. Whether youre a rider that wants an on-the-limit race-tuned performance or just want to feel safer and more secure, the disc brake has to fulfill all those expectations, as well as be reliable, easy to maintain, lightweight and, ideally, affordable. No, not really. Way more modulation, stopping power, and just as smooth. When we examined the braking torque graphs, we could see that when it comes to brakes, power is secondary to the pad material. Download the app for iOS or Android to read all articles on your tablet or smartphone. Ensure you tighten the top up to 4nm first and then the bottom to 4nm. I went for a ride on my usually test loop and realised how dependent I had become on my rear break and came into a section way too hot and went over the bars. Punching in as Magura's lowest-priced brake is this MT Trail at 80 USD per wheel. But I cant find anywhere locally to test them on a bike so: I have the Maguras and love them. The rebuildability of the Formulas is what I find appealing, as well as the good reviews and polished silver color option. https://www.bike-discount.de/en/buy/magura-mt5-mt4-carbotecture-r-disk-brake-set-566442. I do want to replace the pads, any good links to get them at a decent price? You are using an out of date browser. What is it about the xt levers that is better than maguras? Mountain Bike Brake Sets | Jenson USA Magura MT Trail Sport disc brake review - MBR MAGURA MT: Installation. Mechanics Quick Question Thread [Ask Questions Here], Deutschen Fhrerschein kaufen Fhrerschein Klasse B kaufen (https://counterfeitdocument.com), Dirt Jump Bikes. But dont be concerned about the weight. Required fields are marked *, New Parts HAUL! Apparently they are a bitch to bleed though. So, I'd get a "pro" kit and bleed them yourself. Photo: Jason Lorch. Is there there a better dual piston brake on the market? Magura is half the price of Shimano. We would never compromise braking performance in an effort to save weight and its time we stop confining powerful brakes to downhill bikes. But I can't find anywhere locally to test them on a bike so: Which one to get? Magura MT 7 Pro brakes review - BikeRadar Even on steep sections, the range of modulation allows for much more controlled descending, when needed. The best MTB disc brake you can buy | Page 9 of 20 | ENDURO The two-piston MT4 variety is on call for skid duty out back. Contacto Telfono: +34 626 486 568 Email: contacto@mountainbikeshop.es. During this process we saw the braking torque increase around 60% from the first pull to the last pull. This would give us a realistic, not theoretical indication of a brakes power from a firm pull. Photo: Jason Lorch, The brake pads are super-easy to replace with the magnetic snap-in system. For those looking for the best all-rounder, with enough power to haul down high-speed mistakes with gentle finesse, then the new SRAM Code brakes tick every box. Unruly. Magura Remmen - Laagste prijzen - Veilig Betalen. I don't know that I've ever seen rebuild kits for calipers or master cylinders in stock anywhere. Magura Trail Sports are supposed to be decent brakes, but I have zero familiarity with Magura. Being different, I wanted to try some Maguras. Bedding in your brake pads makes a huge difference to their performance. There are several options: (1) have a very keen eye or, (2) use shimano rotors which are the miniumum required width for the brake system. JavaScript is disabled. Together with his young family and two crazy dogs, you will almost always find him outdoors. Thanks to a modified geometry they can be ridden closer to the handlebars, resulting in increased control and more comfort on long descents. Continental Trail King Continental Argotal . Magura MT Trail Sport upgrade from XT M8000 | Rotorburn The reach adjustment is flush with the lever blade. Power, we know, is important, but what is more important is how the brake doses out that power on the trail: modulation and reliability are king. $22.99. Interested in experience with the Maguras also. The HC storm rotors recommended by Magura are slightly thicker than those on the market. Parts for Shimano brakes are pretty common. The new Shiftmix 4 handlebar clamp combines a Shimano I-Spec EV shifter and a Magura brake master in a single clamp. While not as ergonomic for me, as their generously hooked aluminum or carbon HC levers, the Trail brakes feature the same Carbotecture Sport blades I ran on my four year old MT 5 system for the winter in my quest to manage issues with cold digits. The MT Trail setup we tested came with a pair of Magura Storm HC rotors. Over two days, we challenged each brake on Hope Technologys computer controlled dynamometer. More power and also good feel. The two options im stuck on are Magura MT5s With HC Rotors 203 up front and 180 out back or Shimano M7000 SLX's and 203 RM66 up front . This smooth linear curve offers an impressive range of lever/brake feedback to apply a much higher level of control on the trails. Though he was born in England, he believes he should have been Scottish. Tires were standardised to the excellent Maxxis Minion DHF/DHRII and thousands of kilometers of trail were shredded. Video. I ride mostly all mountain and trail. Brake pads are not "parts", they better damn be available, or what, you throw out the brake after you wear down some pads? We recommend a minimum of 200/180 mm for general riding. Shimano SLX Trail M7120 - Mantel Click here and see how they are made! What size rotors are you running? At the affordable end of the market, the SRAM Guide T disappointed testers with its low power, while the Shimano Deore delivered the same great value as ever. MT2, 4, 6, and 8 for the two-piston systems and MT5, and 7 for the four-piston systems. Lokal. Disc temperatures reached over 400 C during this savage test, and fade was evident in most brakes gas produced from hot pad resin decreasing friction. Frankenstein was a story (sorry, folks) but this is reality! The MTTS feel a bit less grabby than the XT. Here's a link to a comment overviewing the HOW I hope that workslol. For . 2021 Zeb upgrades - luftkappe or new air spring? DVO appreciation and support thread (AKA the Ced Thread) - Pics, ride reports and discussion, The Sexiest AM/FR/Enduro Hardtail Thread (Please read the opening post), Bleeding Disc Brakes for the first time, seeking info, Post Your Road Bikes (Read 1st post for guide), Rad retro MTB stuff [MTB of any discipline], SantaCruz Bikes up to 25% off & NO SALES TAX at Owenhouse Bikes Bozeman Montana, Report Scammers on Pinkbike HERE *Read 1st Post* then contact captainbringdown directly, Crunching 3 easiest gears on Shimano Saint drivetrain. I hope what we do here at Tyres and Soles will inspire people to get out there and experience first hand, the natural wonders that surround them. After riding the brakes for a while, I can swap out the rear caliper with an MT5 one and boom! When needing to quickly scrub speed, the bite on the MT Trail Sport did not disappoint. Shimano every time ! Components - Brakes. MSRP $309.00 (38) Award Winner. There is no reason for them to get spongy again unless they are defective. So what are the best shimano 4 pot brakes then? This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register. Magura USA Storm HC 6-Bolt Rotor One Color, 203mm. Brakes are now so powerful that given enough force on the lever, each possesses the potential to transmit far more braking torque than could ever be transferred by a mountain bike tire. Magura MT Trail, But then, I'd be happily throwing down for the Trail Sport to get the four-piston caliper bolted to my fork so I'm not really the market for this setup. Ive used this setup for a couple years and it is fantastic. Similar names aside, these Sport brakes shouldn't be confused with the MT Trail Sport brakes I've tested at purchase time. MT7 Pros on fast bikes that go down hill, and Trails on anything else. MT Trail Sport. Now you dont need to overthink your braking, just let the natural braking abilities of the 4 and 2 piston combination to take care of it for you. Thats what Ive read around and ehy Im considering them even though my usual go-to manufacturer is Shimano. Cold hard numbers in the laboratory are one thing, but taking a brake to the trail is the ultimate test. Ive also found some of the Shimano ZEE 4 pots on Ebay for 230$ or so. By the end of testing, we had uncovered five laws of deceleration. Whether it's teaching Brook to ride trails, hammering out gravel loops, surfing, skiing or canoeing, hell be there no matter the weather, like a true Scotsman. Trying to save some money if possible. 4 front pistons for maximum braking power, 2 rear. Its not very hard to get good value brakes as entry level models such as Code Rs and Shimano Zees offer the same power as the top models with less adjustability. Magura USA website has good stock and prices. What other parts are you talking about? 100% free! Comfort pads installed out back. They make the MT Trail bite like a Formula Cura, which is my benchmark for two-piston systems, but with a more gentle initialization that some riders will prefer. Magura MT7 or Shimano XT 4 pots? - Singletrack World Magazine Some of the brakes would initially deliver high braking torques, but within a second, as the pad heated up, braking torque would fall off dramaticallythis is all due to the efficiency of the pad material. I have MT7s on my Specialized Stumpy. Sure enough they burped a big bubble when I did. This is the new Focus Jam2 and Sam2. . I'm also a bit of a muso and enjoy a good craft beer every now and again (probably too often). Magura MT8 vs XTR M9000 ? . Nonetheless, demonstrating that you can teach an old dog new tricks, he continues to hold his own against the wild and fearless youth. The only brakes i have ever ridden that are anywhere near them are the new hayes 4pots. Shimano I-Spec I+II, SRAM Matchmaker, Shimano I-Spec EV: PU: Set: Service . Riding fast is one of the best feelings: we argue over KOMs in the pub and agonise over reviews telling us we need a bigger wheel size to keep up with our buddies. Yeap, we're up in your social medias too. For most riding a standard dual up front will be just fine. But tell us all about it when you get back. MAGURA Trail Sport discbrake Magura MT Trail Sport From 172.76. From the ultimate nightmare to an inspiring recovery. Cost-saving calipers. MAGURAs proven trail concept is a price/performance miracle compared to other brake packages on the market. Magura's MT Trail lever with the new OEM one-finger aluminum lever blade option. Only 7 left in stock - order soon. Are you kidding? Copyright 2023 ENDURO Mountainbike Magazine. Both the MT Trail Sport and MT5 use Carbotecture for their lever bodies. The way to make XT brakes feel like Maguras is to replace the calipers on your XTs with 4 piston Magura calipers. What you get with the MT Sport Trail is a system that has been designed from numerous Magura riders mixing different piston combinations to dial in the best braking system. Every year, tires get better, our bikes get more capable, riding standards increase and we ride on more challenging terrain. (his son) are inscribed on his top tube as a gentle warning against unruly riding. I just recently replaced the rotors. The Race pads make this as good as any two-piston brake on the market in terms of feel and power. Min-Maxing, Saints on my Kenevo super powerful and so bloody easy to bleed ! Shimano Shimano XT M8100 Resin J-Kit Achterrem . The XT's lever blades are a bit thinner. . Magura MT Trail Brakes - Review - Pinkbike 203mm up front and a 180mm at the rear. To go fast, we need to be able to go slow, so which disc brake is best? Theyre well designed and able to dispense 100% of their power with control and beautiful modulation. A forum community dedicated to Mountain Bike owners and enthusiasts. 1 set (caliper + lever) of Hope E4 or X2 = 2 sets (caliper + lever) of Magura Trail Sport. Grab a mate, a partner, a pet and head out into nature. Magura MT Sport There was less rear brake to help skid around some corners and more emphasis on using the front brakes to scrub most of the speed and focusing more on modulating the rear to avoid any unnecessary skidding. Magura Brakes, As a reminder of his new role as a father, the words Think about Brook." Magura MT 7 Pro Magura br_brakeSystems BR1735 8/9/3/d . Whisky, riding his bike and everything in between. We conducted extensive optimisation to determine a real-world lever pressure, activating the lever with a mechanical finger at a constant force of 40N, around 9 lbs of pressure, equivalent to the firm pull of a human finger. While the levers are made of alloy. Magura Storm Rohloff Disque Frein Rotor 180mm 4-Bolt Argent So, pump up those tyres, don your favourite boots. IMO the MT Trail Sport are better as they come with the short lever pre installed whereas its an optional, expensive, retro fit upgrade on the MT5/4. I run Maguras MT7's on my Slash. The B Practice Podcast crew discusses if adding more points-paying runs per round will water down the intensity of racing due to riders focusing more on consistency and the season overall. It is easy to compare brakes in the same way as we would compare a cars performance: more power = more performance, right? Anchor awaay! For those who live in the Alps, carry excess weight or simply hunger for brute power, the Magura MT7 and Shimano Saint models are hard to beat for value and power. The MT Trail's are an MT7 up front and an MT5 rear. Using the ergonomic aluminium HC lever, the MT Trail Sports offer all the benefits of the super bling Trail Carbon, but at a fraction of the . The 280 USD Trail Sport system can go up against brakes that cost twice as much, including any that Magura makes. I'd suspect you shop is not doing the best job bleeding them. Priced at: $330.00 .approx (without rotors). They dont feel as touchy as Shimano brakes, which tend to have an on/off feeling but there is a small bit of modulation at the beginning of the stroke, so you dont always scrub off too much speed when a light touch is needed. I am running a MT5 in the front and MT4 on the rear and really love them, even with the stock pads they feel stronger than the Saints they replaced. The MT Trail Sport is intended to serve the demands of todays riders while taking aim at value and performance in one shot. They only sell the entire lever. 2 reviews for the price of almost one and I get to keep my short levers! Initially, I was impressed with the ergonomics of the levers. The best MTB disc brake you can buy Magura MT Trail Sport Disc Brake 4yJ8A-m33979159738 Einfach. eBay Kleinanzeigen - Kostenlos. Magura MT5 or MT7 - much more powerful and less fade, much more feel, even on big alpine days. MT Trail Sport. Photo: Jason Lorch, Spurcycle Silicone Grips Accessory Review, FIRST LOOK SENDHIT Stanchion Scratch Repair, Backcountry Mutherload Strap Accessory Review. Feel more robust. Magura's MT7 front caliper uses four small top-loading pads. MAGURA MT: Installation. They are supposed to be easy to bleed, good performers, and are priced fairly. Frenos Magura MT4 Flatmount para uso MTB, vlido para freno delantero y trasero, aportando gran estabilidad y modulacin. I doubt it. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Magura MT Trail Sport Disc Brake 4yJ8A-m33979159738 - > > ()2~3 ,, . Good power, nice lever feel, but a bit on/off. Does not matter which model as the calipers are the same among models. IMO xt is kinda on/off braking (rough said) and the maguras is more gradually braking. Once, he was in love with competition and raced in the early years of the EWS, but now, at 41-years-old, he no longer has anything to prove. nothing else is even close. We ran the MT Trail Sport brakes on a long-travel 29er hardtail. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. Good brake pad material is the essential ingredient for powerful deceleration, sintered pads use metal shavings for maximum performance on long runs, while organic pads have a very powerful bite. Hands down best stopping power Ive ever experienced. Im a die hard Magura fan. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Both offer 4-pot front + 2-pot rear caliper. So much more power than the old Shimano set up. Get it as soon as Tuesday, Mar 7. Iniciar sesin; Crear una cuenta; Bienvenido, Iniciar sesin o Crear una cuenta. Tags: best mountain bike brakesBrakeset reviewMaguraMagura brakeset reviewMagura MT trail sportMagura mt trail sport reviewmagura mt5magura mt5 reviewmountain bike brake reviewtrailtalkmtb, Your email address will not be published. MT TRAIL SPORT, 1-finger HC lever blade | Disc brakes Thanks for all of the replies thus far, I appreciate the responses! Now I dont have a spongy feel or long leaver travel. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, Colorado.Evil Offering V2,Commencal Absolut. The Magura MT Trail Sport, pound for pound, one of the best performing brake setups. Be aware that the MT7 and MT5 calipers are identical (sans color, obv). So worried im going to break something when servicing them. I used Magura barbs and Shimano Olives to complete the conversion. Magura Sport Trail vs TRP Slate vs Shimano SLX-ish The result is a clean, uncluttered look. The E-MOUNTAINBIKE Print Edition 2022 is our fifth annual edition and the ultimate guide in your search for the perfect eMTB. It may seem crazy but pulling on the rear brake often causes you to skid out of control, and control is what you need when it comes to braking. Magura MT 5's or Shimano SLX's ? - Pinkbike Forum Heres a link to a comment overviewing the HOW, I hope that workslol. Les meilleures offres pour Magura Storm Rohloff Disque Frein Rotor 180mm 4-Bolt Argent sont sur eBay Comparez les prix et les spcificits des produits neufs et d 'occasion Pleins d 'articles en livraison gratuite! I've done some looking around and have narrowed it down to two options. Warranty and customer service sucks. ENDURO Mountainbike Magazine is published in a digital app format in both English and German. Magur MT trail sport vs Shimano Trail sport Magura is half the price of Shimano. The price/performance winner in the trail segment: . Overall, the brakes come in at 459g on our scales (with a 900mm front hose, 1,650mm . The HC storm rotors recommended by Magura are slightly thicker than those on the market. Press J to jump to the feed. I just cured my spongy long throw SRAM guides on my expert, by pushing the pads manually all the way back into the Caliper. Dont forget aftermarket pads too: in our tests fitting the Trickstuff Power+ brake pads to the SRAM Code R resulted in a 20% improvement in average braking torque, and an average of 18% improvement in deceleration times. Instead, I use 2.3mm ebike rotors and the power is nutty. ie, keep the existing disks and mounts ? Mineral Oil and DOT fluid have similar boiling points: DOT can absorb moisture from the environment and lose performance, while this is rare in a sealed brake DOT is toxic and corrosive, damaging your bikes paintwork if spilled and harmful to the environment and your skin. New shared architecture Drivetrain components from Shimano. At the other end of the price spectrum the Trickstuff Direttissima are unequalled if you lust for the best modulation and power, but they are so expensive that only those with the fattest wallets are likely to enjoy them.

Carlson Center Fairbanks Events, How To Make A Homemade Plan B Pill, Articles M